#include <bits/stdc++.h> using namespace std; voi...

Created on: May 7, 2025

Answered using O3 by Chat01

Question

#include <bits/stdc++.h>
using namespace std;

void solve(){
int n, k;
cin >> n >> k;

text
vector<int> ans(n, 0); int val = k-(n-2); if(val<=0){ cout << -1 << "\n"; return; } ans[n-2] = val; ans[n-1] = val*2; for(int i=n-3; i>=0; i--){ ans[i] = --val; } for(int i=0; i<n; i++){ cout << ans[i] << " "; } cout << "\n";

}

int main() {
// your code goes here
int t;
cin >> t;
while(t--){
solve();
}

}

'''
GCD Summation
For an array
A
A of length
N
N, we define
f
(
A
)
f(A) to be the sum of GCDs of its adjacent elements, i.e.

f
(
A
)


i

1
N

1
gcd

(
A
i
,
A
i
+
1
)
f(A)=
i=1

N−1

gcd(A
i

,A
i+1

)
You are given two integers
N
N and
K
K.
Find any array
A
A of length
N
N, consisting of distinct integers between
1
1 and
1
0
9
10
9
, such that
f
(
A
)

K
f(A)=K.

If multiple valid arrays exist, you may find any of them.
If no valid arrays exist, print

1
−1 instead.

Input Format
The first line of input will contain a single integer
T
T, denoting the number of test cases.
The first and only line of each test case contains two space-separated integers
N
N and
K
K – the length of the array and the required value of
f
(
A
)
f(A), respectively.
Output Format
For each test case, on a new line:

If no valid array exists, print the single integer

1
−1.
Otherwise, output
N
N space-separated integers
A
1
,
A
2
,

,
A
N
A
1

,A
2

,…,A
N

, representing the array you found.
Each
A
i
A
i

should be an integer between
1
1 and
1
0
9
10
9
, and
f
(
A
)

K
f(A)=K must hold. The elements of
A
A must be pairwise distinct, i.e.
A
i

A
j
A
i

=A
j

for
i

j
i=j.
If there are multiple valid arrays, you may find any of them.

Constraints
1

T

1
0
5
1≤T≤10
5

2

N

2

1
0
5
2≤N≤2⋅10
5

1

K

1
0
6
1≤K≤10
6

The sum of
N
N over all test cases won't exceed
2

1
0
5
2⋅10
5
.
Sample 1:
Input
Output
3
3 5
5 3
5 18
15 54 8
-1
9 210 72 30 57
Explanation:
Test case
1
1: We have
A

[
15
,
54
,
8
]
A=[15,54,8], for which
f
(
A
)

gcd

(
15
,
54
)
+
gcd

(
54
,
8
)

3
+
2

5
f(A)=gcd(15,54)+gcd(54,8)=3+2=5, as required.

Test case
2
2: It can be proved that there does not exist any array of length
5
5, with distinct integers between
1
1 and
1
0
9
10
9
, such that the sum of adjacent GCDs equals
3
3.

Test case
3
3: We have
f
(
A
)

gcd

(
9
,
210
)
+
gcd

(
210
,
72
)
+
gcd

(
72
,
30
)
+
gcd

(
30
,
57
)

3
+
6
+
6
+
3

18
f(A)=gcd(9,210)+gcd(210,72)+gcd(72,30)+gcd(30,57)=3+6+6+3=18.
'''

What is the problem with my code for the problem in quotes? Correct it and give me the correct code in my template in cpp

Thought

Analyzing user's code

The user shared a code snippet alongside the problem statement, asking for help correcting their code. The task is to find an array of distinct integers such that the sum of GCDs of adjacent elements equals K, given two numbers, N and K. The input size can be large, up to 200,000 elements. I'll need to carefully evaluate the code to pinpoint the error and offer a correct solution in the desired template. If the problem is unsolvable, I'll return -1. Let’s dig into it!

Analyzing user's code

The user's approach calculates the value val as k - (n-2), then sets certain elements in the array such that GCDs of adjacent pairs sum up to K. However, the logic is incorrect regarding how the GCDs will sum. The user’s attempt to adjust values for the sum is based on the assumption that the GCD of adjacent elements will always be val, but that's too simplistic.

The strategy needs refinement, where you can generate a pattern where most GCDs are 1, and one pair contributes a larger GCD.

Refining approach

The user's logic needs some refinement. Their approach works for larger values of K but fails when K is close to N-2, as filling descending values can lead to negative numbers and duplicates. When K is small, it becomes impossible to generate distinct, valid values. To address this, an adjustment can be made: using a sequence of small distinct numbers, possibly primes, for the first N-2 positions to avoid issues with duplicates or negative values later. This solution makes sure the GCD conditions are met while avoiding conflicts with adjacent numbers.

Designing the algorithm

To ensure the array is distinct and maintains the GCD condition, I propose initializing the first N-2 values as distinct and ensuring no duplicates with val or 2*val. Next, I'll make sure the last two values have the desired GCD, and if needed, adjust the iteration by adding some offsets. This prevents any overlap and targets the required GCD constraints while ensuring the output is valid. The key observation here is to choose numbers where adjacent pairs have GCD=1, except for the last pair.

Thought for 6m 9s

Answer

What went wrong?
Your construction is based on the neat observation

f(A) = (N‑2)·1 + val      with   val = K – (N‑2)

i.e. make every adjacent GCD equal 1 except one special pair
⟨val , 2·val⟩ whose GCD is val.
That idea is perfectly fine, but the loop

cpp
for (int i = n-3; i >= 0; --i) ans[i] = --val;

keeps decrementing val until it reaches 0 or becomes negative whenever
K is close to its minimum possible value N‑1.
Consequently you output zero / negative numbers, and sometimes you even repeat val — both of which violate the statement (“distinct integers between 1 and 10^9”).


A robust construction

  1. Impossible case – the smallest sum we can ever obtain is N‑1 (all adjacent GCDs equal 1).
    If K < N‑1 we print ‑1.

  2. Exactly the minimum (K = N‑1) – just output consecutive integers 1 … N; every pair is coprime ⇒ sum of GCDs = N‑1.

  3. General case (K > N‑1)

text
x = K – (N‑2) (now x &ge; 2) [A0 … AN‑3] = BASE, BASE+1, …, BASE+(N‑3) // BASE = 3'000'003 AN‑2 = 1 AN‑1 = x AN = 2·x
  • the BASE block is a stretch of consecutive numbers ⇒ every GCD inside it is 1;
  • gcd(BASE+(N‑3), 1) = 1;
  • gcd(1, x) = 1;
  • gcd(x, 2x) = x.

Hence the total is (N‑3 – 1)·1 + 1 + 1 + x = (N‑2)+x = K,
all numbers are positive, distinct and ≤ 10^9 (largest is BASE+(N‑3) < 3.3 &times; 10^6).


Correct code (C++ 17)

cpp
#include <bits/stdc++.h> using namespace std; using ll = long long; void solve() { ll N, K; // N up to 2·10^5, K up to 10^6 cin >> N >> K; /* impossible ----------------------------------------------- */ if (K < N - 1) { cout << -1 << '\n'; return; } /* N = 2 is a special one‑pair case ------------------------- */ if (N == 2) { cout << K << ' ' << 2 * K << '\n'; // gcd = K return; } /* exactly the minimum sum ---------------------------------- */ if (K == N - 1) { // x would be 1 for (ll i = 1; i <= N; ++i) cout << i << (i == N ? '\n' : ' '); return; } /* general constructive case -------------------------------- */ ll x = K - (N - 2); // x &ge; 2 const ll BASE = 3'000'003; // > 2·10^6, well < 10^9 vector<ll> a; a.reserve(N); /* 1) a block whose consecutive elements are pairwise coprime */ for (ll i = 0; i < N - 3; ++i) a.push_back(BASE + i); // gcd of neighbours = 1 /* 2) a bridging 1 so that gcd(… ,1) and gcd(1,x) are both 1 */ a.push_back(1); /* 3) the special pair whose gcd is x */ a.push_back(x); a.push_back(2 * x); /* output ---------------------------------------------------- */ for (size_t i = 0; i < a.size(); ++i) cout << a[i] << (i + 1 == a.size() ? '\n' : ' '); } int main() { ios::sync_with_stdio(false); cin.tie(nullptr); int T; cin >> T; while (T--) solve(); return 0; }

This keeps every element within the required range, guarantees pairwise distinctness, and works in O(N) per test‑case — easily fast enough for the given limits.

Question

Hey, instead of the base concept, can you use my concept itself to build the answer? I did not understand the base concept.

Question

Hey, instead of the base concept, can you use my concept itself to build the answer? I did not understand the base concept.

Thought

Reevaluating user's concept

The user wants to use their own concept directly to build the answer since they didn't understand the base idea we used before. Their approach involves choosing val = k - (n - 2) and setting up ans[n-2] = val and ans[n-1] = val*2. They also fill the other positions with descending values from val-1. However, they require val > 0, else output -1. There are issues with duplicates or negative values due to the descending order. I will keep the GCD of earlier pairs as 1, except for the final pair where the GCD is val.

Simplifying the approach

I think we can improve the approach by choosing small primes or numbers to ensure gcd(...) = 1 for all pairs, except the last one. The descending loop isn't needed. Using the first n-2 prime numbers starting with 2 works because consecutive primes have gcd = 1. I'll add val and 2*val at the end. To keep the sum consistent, we need gcd(prime_{n-2}, val) = 1. For the rest of the numbers, I’ll use integers starting from 3 to ensure gcd = 1 between consecutive numbers.

Thought for 56 seconds

Answer

Below is a drop‑in replacement for your file that keeps your original idea—
only one special pair contributes val to the sum, every other adjacent GCD is 1.
I only fixed the edge cases and the way the first n‑2 numbers are filled.

cpp
#include <bits/stdc++.h> using namespace std; using ll = long long; void solve() { ll n, k; cin >> n >> k; /* 1. Impossible when the minimum achievable sum (n‑1) is larger than k */ if (k < n - 1) { cout << -1 << '\n'; return; } /* 2. Trivial minimum‑sum case: consecutive integers 1 … n */ if (k == n - 1) { for (ll i = 1; i <= n; ++i) cout << i << (i == n ? '\n' : ' '); return; } /* 3. General case ------------------------------------------------------ */ ll val = k - (n - 2); // gcd of the last pair (val , 2·val) if (n == 2) { // special when there is only that one pair cout << val << ' ' << 2 * val << '\n'; return; } vector<ll> a; a.reserve(n); /* first n‑3 numbers: consecutive integers starting from 3 (they guarantee gcd=1 with neighbours) */ ll cur = 3; for (int i = 0; i < n - 3; ++i) { while (cur == val || cur == 2 * val) ++cur; // keep all values distinct a.push_back(cur++); } /* the final three numbers: 1, val, 2·val gcd( … , 1) = 1, gcd(1 , val) = 1, gcd(val , 2·val) = val */ a.push_back(1); a.push_back(val); a.push_back(2 * val); /* output --------------------------------------------------------------- */ for (size_t i = 0; i < a.size(); ++i) cout << a[i] << (i + 1 == a.size() ? '\n' : ' '); } int main() { ios::sync_with_stdio(false); cin.tie(nullptr); int t; cin >> t; while (t--) solve(); return 0; }

Why this keeps your concept intact

  • Your key idea: choose val = K – (N‑2), make the last pair
    val, 2·val⟩ so that their GCD equals val.
    That part is unchanged.

  • Every other adjacent GCD is forced to 1:

    • consecutive integers are always coprime → gcd = 1;
    • gcd(anything, 1) = 1.
  • Hence
    f(A) = (N‑3)·1 // between the leading block + 1 // between last block element and the 1 + val // between val and 2·val = N‑2 + val = K.

  • All numbers are distinct and far below 10^9
    (k &le; 10^6 &rArr; 2·val &le; 2.2 &times; 10^6 at worst).

So the construction obeys the constraints while following exactly the pattern you originally envisioned.

Share this Q&A