Max visits per domain

Created on: February 4, 2025

Answered using O1 by Chat01

Question

I have a query to find out counters SELECT CounterID, sum(Sign) AS visits FROM visits_all WHERE StartDate = toDate('2024-02-04') AND StartURLDomain = 'vtb.ru' GROUP BY CounterID ORDER BY visits DESC;

I want you to modify it to find counters with max visits value for all dates and for each domain found in the table

Thought

Revisiting the query

I’m focusing on tweaking a SQL query to determine the top counters by visits for each domain on all dates. This involves grouping and sorting by visits and reconsidering the aggregation approach.

Piecing together the needs

I’m thinking through whether each domain-date pair should have a single row with the top counter by visits, or if just the top counter for each domain across all dates suffices.

Piecing together options

I’m examining SQL query structures to identify counters with maximum visits for each domain and date, considering aggregations and filtering to ensure accurate domain tallying.

Focusing on domain clusters

Mapping out cliques based on traits like gender and age, I aim to find overlapping areas where these groups intersect to see where the maximum interactions occur.

Focusing on core elements

I’m narrowing down to selecting each domain's top counter, aiming to pinpoint the one with the highest visits. This ensures clarity and precision in the selection process.

Clarifying the request

OK, let me see. The request likely involves identifying each domain's top counter across all dates, without focusing on date-specific top counters.

Clarifying the scope

Hmm, I’m thinking they might be looking for the top counter for each domain across all dates. This approach should streamline things and avoid overcomplicating.

Reasoned about SQL query modification for 40 seconds

Answer

Below is one common way (using ClickHouse’s argMax function) to modify your query so that, for each domain, you get the single counter that has the maximum total “visits” across all dates in the table.

SELECT StartURLDomain, argMax(CounterID, total_visits) AS CounterWithMaxVisits, max(total_visits) AS MaxVisits FROM ( -- Sum Sign by domain and counter for all dates SELECT StartURLDomain, CounterID, SUM(Sign) AS total_visits FROM visits_all GROUP BY StartURLDomain, CounterID ) GROUP BY StartURLDomain ORDER BY MaxVisits DESC

Explanation

  1. Innermost SELECT:

    • We remove the WHERE clause so we look across all dates instead of a single date.
    • We group by (StartURLDomain, CounterID) and sum up Sign to get total visits per (domain, counter) pair.
  2. Outer SELECT:

    • For each domain (StartURLDomain) we:
      • Use argMax(CounterID, total_visits) to pick the one CounterID that has the highest total_visits for that domain.
      • Use max(total_visits) to show the largest summed Sign (i.e., visits) for that domain.
  3. ORDER BY:

    • Finally, we sort by MaxVisits DESC so that the domain with the largest number of visits appears first in the result set.

If you want the top counter per domain per date

If instead you need the top counter for each date and for each domain, include StartDate in the grouping and outer query:

SELECT StartURLDomain, StartDate, argMax(CounterID, total_visits) AS CounterWithMaxVisits, max(total_visits) AS MaxVisits FROM ( SELECT StartURLDomain, StartDate, CounterID, SUM(Sign) AS total_visits FROM visits_all GROUP BY StartURLDomain, StartDate, CounterID ) GROUP BY StartURLDomain, StartDate ORDER BY StartURLDomain, StartDate

That will return, for each (domain, date), the counter with the highest total visits, plus the maximum visit count for that pair.

Question

use ordinary sql dialect

Thought

Building the query

I’m constructing a SQL query to identify the CounterID with the maximum total visits for each domain. Using subqueries in the HAVING clause to compare sums is an option.

Refining the query

I'm exploring the use of window functions, specifically ROW_NUMBER, to efficiently identify the CounterID with the maximum visits for each domain. This approach leverages partitioning and ordering to streamline the process.

Finalizing the method

I’m showing how to use window functions with ROW_NUMBER to pinpoint the CounterID with top visits for each domain. This method is compatible with modern SQL dialects like Postgres and MySQL 8+.

Reasoned about SQL query modification for 11 seconds

Answer

Below are two approaches in standard SQL (often referred to as “ordinary SQL”) for selecting, for each domain, the single counter with the maximum total visits across all dates.


1) Using a Window Function (Modern SQL)

If your SQL engine supports window functions (e.g., PostgreSQL, MySQL 8+, SQL Server, Oracle, etc.), you can use ROW_NUMBER() or RANK() to pick the row with the highest sum of visits per domain:

SELECT StartURLDomain, CounterID, total_visits FROM ( SELECT StartURLDomain, CounterID, SUM(Sign) AS total_visits, ROW_NUMBER() OVER ( PARTITION BY StartURLDomain ORDER BY SUM(Sign) DESC ) AS rn FROM visits_all GROUP BY StartURLDomain, CounterID ) AS sub WHERE rn = 1 ORDER BY total_visits DESC;

Explanation:

  1. GROUP BY (StartURLDomain, CounterID) to aggregate SUM(Sign) as total_visits.
  2. Use ROW_NUMBER() OVER (PARTITION BY StartURLDomain ORDER BY total_visits DESC) to rank counters within each domain, from largest to smallest.
  3. Filter the result to only include the row where ROW_NUMBER() = 1, i.e., the maximum row.
  4. ORDER BY total_visits DESC at the end to list the highest overall domain+counter pair first.

2) Using a Self-Join (Pre-Window Functions)

For older databases that do not support window functions, you can achieve the same result with a self-join. The idea is to select rows that have no other row in the same domain with a strictly larger sum of visits:

SELECT t.StartURLDomain, t.CounterID, t.total_visits FROM ( -- Summarize visits per (domain, counter). SELECT StartURLDomain, CounterID, SUM(Sign) AS total_visits FROM visits_all GROUP BY StartURLDomain, CounterID ) AS t LEFT JOIN ( SELECT StartURLDomain, CounterID, SUM(Sign) AS total_visits FROM visits_all GROUP BY StartURLDomain, CounterID ) AS t2 ON t.StartURLDomain = t2.StartURLDomain AND t.total_visits < t2.total_visits WHERE t2.total_visits IS NULL ORDER BY t.total_visits DESC;

Explanation:

  1. We build a subquery t and a subquery t2 (actually the same aggregation, just aliased differently).
  2. We LEFT JOIN them on the condition that (t.StartURLDomain = t2.StartURLDomain) and t.total_visits < t2.total_visits.
    • If t2.total_visits is not NULL, it means there is another row in the same domain that has a strictly larger total, so t is not the maximum.
  3. WHERE t2.total_visits IS NULL means we only keep t rows that have no strictly larger total in the same domain — i.e., the maximum in that domain.
  4. Finally, we sort descending by t.total_visits.

Either approach will give you a single row per domain (when there is a strict maximum). If ties exist, you can adapt the join or window function logic to allow for multiple rows (e.g., using RANK() for ties).


If you also need to break it down by date

If you wanted the top counter per domain for each date, simply include StartDate in both the grouping and the window partition (or in the self-join condition). For example, with window functions:

SELECT StartURLDomain, StartDate, CounterID, total_visits FROM ( SELECT StartURLDomain, StartDate, CounterID, SUM(Sign) AS total_visits, ROW_NUMBER() OVER ( PARTITION BY StartURLDomain, StartDate ORDER BY SUM(Sign) DESC ) AS rn FROM visits_all GROUP BY StartURLDomain, StartDate, CounterID ) AS sub WHERE rn = 1 ORDER BY StartURLDomain, StartDate, total_visits DESC;

That way, you get one CounterID per (domain, date) with the highest visit count.

Share this Q&A