生成初步评审意见,2个优点,5个缺点,优点强调对教育领域的启发,缺点例如图2The human ev...
Tạo vào: 20 tháng 11, 2026
Trả lời bằng GPT-6 Thinking bởi Chat01
Tạo vào: 20 tháng 11, 2026
Trả lời bằng GPT-6 Thinking bởi Chat01
生成初步评审意见,2个优点,5个缺点,优点强调对教育领域的启发,缺点例如图2The human evaluation framework are shown. 不够清晰
我会按正式审稿意见的语气整理成“2条优点、5条不足”,重点突出对教育领域的启发,并结合图2及实验结果提出具体、可修改的问题。
以下是针对论文 Fine-Tuned Large Language Model for Personalized and Efficient Lean Manufacturing Training 的英文初步审稿意见,包括2个优点和5个不足。整体语气客观、建设性,优点突出对教育领域的启发,不足涵盖图表清晰度、实验设计与方法有效性。
:::writing{variant="document" id="58321"}
1. Potential implications for AI-assisted education.
The manuscript explores the application of fine-tuned large language models to lean manufacturing training, offering valuable insights into AI-assisted education. The proposed approach has the potential to support personalized and interactive learning while reducing the time and costs associated with traditional training. This study may also provide useful inspiration for the development of domain-specific intelligent tutoring systems in other educational and professional training contexts.
2. Integration of multiple evaluation perspectives.
The proposed HOMES framework integrates automatic evaluation metrics with human assessments from both trainees and domain experts. This evaluation strategy is a positive aspect of the study, as it considers not only the technical performance of language models but also their suitability for educational applications. Such a framework could provide useful methodological guidance for evaluating AI-supported educational systems.
1. Limited clarity of Figure 2.
Figure 2, captioned "The human evaluation framework are shown," is not sufficiently clear. The figure contains relatively small text and several densely arranged components, making the evaluation procedure difficult to follow. In particular, the roles of trainee evaluators and domain experts, as well as their relationships with the different output types, should be distinguished more clearly. The authors are encouraged to redesign the figure with a clearer structure and improve the grammatical accuracy of its caption.
2. Insufficient validation of educational effectiveness.
Although the manuscript emphasizes the potential of the proposed approach for personalized and efficient education, the experiments mainly focus on response quality and model performance. There is limited direct evidence demonstrating improvements in learners' knowledge acquisition, learning efficiency, or practical problem-solving abilities. Additional educational experiments, such as pre- and post-training assessments or comparisons with conventional training approaches, would strengthen the practical significance of the study.
3. Concerns regarding the evaluation metrics and numerical consistency.
The definitions of TP, TN, FP, and FN in the proposed evaluation framework differ from their conventional meanings in classification tasks. For example, response length is incorporated into these categories, making it difficult to distinguish factual correctness from response-style preferences. Furthermore, some numerical results appear inconsistent. For instance, the accuracy of the original Gemini model is reported as 0.0034 in Table 6 but 0.034 in Table 12. The authors should clarify the evaluation definitions, justify their suitability, and carefully verify the reported results.
4. Insufficient justification of the proposed hyperparameter optimization method.
The manuscript introduces a sigmoid-based reward-penalty mechanism for hyperparameter optimization. However, the relationship between the proposed reward scores and actual model performance is not sufficiently demonstrated. In particular, the preference for intermediate hyperparameter values requires stronger empirical justification. Comparisons with conventional grid search, random search, or other established optimization methods would help demonstrate the effectiveness and novelty of the proposed strategy.
5. Limited experimental reproducibility and generalizability.
The manuscript would benefit from more detailed descriptions of dataset construction, model training configurations, and evaluation procedures. In addition, the same test dataset appears to be used during preliminary model selection and final evaluation, which may introduce selection bias. The authors should clarify how data leakage was prevented and consider using an independent test set. Providing representative dataset examples, evaluation instructions, and implementation details would further improve the reproducibility and reliability of the findings. :::
初步建议:Major Revision(大修)。 这组意见既肯定了论文在AI辅助职业教育方面的潜在价值,也指出了影响技术可信度的关键问题。其中第3、4、5条属于相对实质性的方法与实验问题,第1条属于图表表达问题。
特别是表6与表12的数值差异,以及算法2主要基于超参数本身计算奖励分数,而非直接采用模型验证性能进行选择,都值得作者进一步解释。