It seems to me that the world of Windows package m...

생성일: 2025년 6월 17일

답변에 사용된 모델 GPT-4.5 by Chat01

질문

It seems to me that the world of Windows package managers is that, the thing is that non of these come pre-installed and it's all a very clunky mess

Also, nobody guarantees your apps will be in that particular manager, unlike in Linux when including your package / library to apt / brew / docker is almost guaranteed / necessary to be appreciated.

답변

Your assessment is spot-on regarding Windows package managers. Here's why this situation exists:

  1. Fragmentation and Lack of Standards:

    • Windows historically lacked a unified package manager. Microsoft introduced their own (winget) relatively recently. Prior to this, third-party solutions (Chocolatey, Scoop) emerged, leading to fragmentation.
  2. No Guarantee of Inclusion:

    • Unlike Linux distributions, where inclusion in the primary repositories (e.g., apt in Debian-based systems) is a major goal for most software developers, Windows package managers don't have the same "gravity" or community-driven momentum.
    • Linux developers see inclusion as essential for visibility and credibility; in contrast, Windows apps traditionally rely on direct downloads from websites or official app stores.
  3. Optional Nature:

    • On Linux, package managers are fundamental to the OS design. Conversely, Windows still primarily relies on manual installers (.exe, .msi files) or official stores. The package managers are often optional, niche solutions.
  4. No Default Integration:

    • winget is gradually becoming standard, but many users aren't aware of it or don't use it. Unlike macOS's brew, which is essentially the de-facto standard despite being third-party, Windows lacks an undisputed leader.

To summarize, the "clunky mess" you describe arises from fragmentation, optionality, and historical reliance on manual software distribution methods. This contrasts strongly with the centralized and community-driven approaches taken by Linux distributions.

이 Q&A 공유하기