fix this and give the updated full zip file { ...

fix this and give the updated full zip file

{
"check_id": "E5",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "detector",
"status": "NA",
"evidence": "verifier does not read an /app output path"
},
{
"check_id": "E1",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "detector",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Dockerfile does not COPY solution/tests/expected into the agent image"
},
{
"check_id": "E2",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "detector",
"status": "NA",
"evidence": "instruction declares no read-only/protected path"
},
{
"check_id": "C4",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "detector",
"status": "NA",
"evidence": "no recompute-from-/app-input pattern, or input is hash-pinned"
},
{
"check_id": "C5",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "detector",
"status": "NA",
"evidence": "no numeric tolerance comparison in verifier"
},
{
"check_id": "D4",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "detector",
"status": "NA",
"evidence": "no RNG used in the verifier/held-out generator"
},
{
"check_id": "A1",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "[3 samples, no break] ",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "FAIL",
"evidence": ""
},
{
"sample": 2,
"status": "FAIL",
"evidence": ""
},
{
"sample": 3,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "I attempted several concrete breaks against the shipped oracle (solution/solve.py) vs the verifier (tests/vault_gauntlet.py), deriving expected values from the spec/data rather than trusting shared logic:\n\n1. **Write-set rule W1 vs W1+W4 divergence ("
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "recall",
"requested": 3,
"observed": 3,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "A2",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: find an instruction-mandated deliverable/action that solution/ only reports on or omits (e.g., producing a report without the actual PostgreSQL vault repair, or skipping the validator script). Refuted \u2014 solution/solve.py:main() performs every mandated action and emits all seven required artifacts: normalize_evidence\u2192normalized_evidence.jsonl (NORMALIZED write in normalize", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: find an instruction-mandated deliverable/action that solution/only reports on or omits (e.g., producing a report without the actual PostgreSQL vault repair, or skipping the validator script). Refuted \u2014solution/solve.py:main()performs every mandated action and emits all seven required artifacts:normalize_evidence\u2192normalized_evidence.jsonl(NORMALIZED write innormalize"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "A3",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: find a decisive graded value (the selected summit, included-tx set, dispositions, digests, or an undisclosed structural constant) baked as a literal in solution/solve.py rather than computed from /app/data.\n\nRefutation \u2014 the reference computes everything from agent-visible inputs:\n- All evidence is loaded from the sealed package, not embedded: solution/solve.py main() read",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: find a decisive graded value (the selected summit, included-tx set, dispositions, digests, or an undisclosed structural constant) baked as a literal in solution/solve.py rather than computed from /app/data.\n\nRefutation \u2014 the reference computes everything from agent-visible inputs:\n- All evidence is loaded from the sealed package, not embedded: solution/solve.py main() read"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "A4",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: (1) the oracle solution/solve.py importing a private CRUX module (a withheld scorer/rule/record-layout the agent cannot derive), and (2) the oracle reading a protected/verifier-only fixture. Both are refuted by the code. The import block solution/solve.py:3-13 is exclusively Python stdlib (hashlib, json, os, re, shutil, stat, subprocess, sys, tempfile, collections.defaultdict", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: (1) the oracle solution/solve.pyimporting a private CRUX module (a withheld scorer/rule/record-layout the agent cannot derive), and (2) the oracle reading a protected/verifier-only fixture. Both are refuted by the code. The import blocksolution/solve.py:3-13 is exclusively Python stdlib (hashlib, json, os, re, shutil, stat, subprocess, sys, tempfile, collections.defaultdict"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "A5",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "[3 samples, no concrete break] Break attempted: I hunted for a silent oracle default in vault_gauntlet.py that grades a decision not derivable from agent-visible material. The strongest candidate is the incarnation fallback in version_before (tests/vault_gauntlet.py, if not eligible: candidates = observed_relation_versions().get(relation, set()); return next(iter(candidates)) if len(candidates)==1 else None), which sile",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: I hunted for a silent oracle default in vault_gauntlet.py that grades a decision not derivable from agent-visible material. The strongest candidate is the incarnation fallback in version_before (tests/vault_gauntlet.py, if not eligible: candidates = observed_relation_versions().get(relation, set()); return next(iter(candidates)) if len(candidates)==1 else None), which sile"
},
{
"sample": 2,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted \u2014 an undocumented upsert-application-order default in the oracle. OUTPUT_CONTRACT.md \u00a7"State gate" only says "Apply each included stamp once to base_state.json\u2026 an upsert replaces any row with the same primary key," and RPS1_SPEC.md \u00a74 repeats this without pinning the order among included packets. Order matters for the one same-PK cross-transaction conflict in the fixed data:"
},
{
"sample": 3,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted \u2014 an undocumented application-order assumption for conflicting upserts. Two included transactions write the same primary key documents.DOC-002: T4005:D (version 44, wal-4-1310-49, lsn 1310) and T4012:D (version 51, wal-4-1450-63, lsn 1450). The final row (and thus logical_state_digest) depends on application order, and the verifier grades the state via a pinned oracle ("
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "precision",
"requested": 3,
"observed": 3,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "A6",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "[3 samples, no break] The graded outputs are pinned against a static verifier-owned fixture (tests/private_expected.json \u2192 ORACLE) and re-derived by independent functions in tests/vault_gauntlet.py; I probed the oracle/re-derivation logic on the shipped sealed scenario for tie/null/subset/filter defects and each attempted break was refuted:\n\n- Break 1 \u2014 feed a tie for the set-inclusion maximum (two valid summit",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "The graded outputs are pinned against a static verifier-owned fixture (tests/private_expected.json \u2192 ORACLE) and re-derived by independent functions in tests/vault_gauntlet.py; I probed the oracle/re-derivation logic on the shipped sealed scenario for tie/null/subset/filter defects and each attempted break was refuted:\n\n- Break 1 \u2014 feed a tie for the set-inclusion maximum (two valid summit"
},
{
"sample": 2,
"status": "FAIL",
"evidence": ""
},
{
"sample": 3,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempts and their code-level defenses:\n\n1. Tie-break / duplicate maximal sets. The shipped scenario ships two candidates with identical included sets: candidate_sets[\"1\"] and candidate_sets[\"3\"] are both the 6-txn {T1001,T1002,T1003,T1004,T1005,T1008} (tests/private_expected.json). A naive "maximum" routine could report two maxima and crash or accept the wrong summit. Refuted:"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "recall",
"requested": 3,
"observed": 3,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "B1",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "[3 samples, no break] Break attempted \u2014 the phrase "complete logical transaction" (RPS1_SPEC.md \u00a73 W2: "admits exactly one complete logical transaction"; \u00a76: "complete logical-transaction atoms ... whose effects match the active incarnation"). I constructed an alternative reading that fits every disclosed constraint and diverges on the graded packet T2007:\n\n- Reading A (reference): "complete" = the logical record's",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted \u2014 the phrase "complete logical transaction" (RPS1_SPEC.md \u00a73 W2: "admits exactly one complete logical transaction"; \u00a76: "complete logical-transaction atoms ... whose effects match the active incarnation"). I constructed an alternative reading that fits every disclosed constraint and diverges on the graded packet T2007:\n\n- Reading A (reference): "complete" = the logical record's"
},
{
"sample": 2,
"status": "FAIL",
"evidence": ""
},
{
"sample": 3,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted \u2014 the rejected_wal reason rule. OUTPUT_CONTRACT.md states: "The local reason precedence is structural_invalid, then crc_invalid, then continuation_invalid, then record_hash_mismatch." This admits two candidate readings: (A) emit only the single highest-precedence reason per row, vs (B) emit the full ordered list of all applicable faults. These diverge only on a re"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "recall",
"requested": 3,
"observed": 3,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "B2",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "[3 samples, no concrete break] Break attempted: a DATA-vs-ORACLE contradiction making the contract unsatisfiable. tests/vault_gauntlet.py check_normalized_trace_atoms simultaneously requires len(rows) == ORACLE['normalized_atom_count'] (206) AND set(atoms) == set(raw_by_atom), where raw_by_atom is built one-per-line over every artifacts/*.jsonl line (for line_no, source in enumerate(sealed_rows(rel), 1): raw_by_ato", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: a DATA-vs-ORACLE contradiction making the contract unsatisfiable. tests/vault_gauntlet.py check_normalized_trace_atomssimultaneously requireslen(rows) == ORACLE['normalized_atom_count'](206) ANDset(atoms) == set(raw_by_atom), where raw_by_atomis built one-per-line over everyartifacts/.jsonl line (for line_no, source in enumerate(sealed_rows(rel), 1): raw_by_ato"
},
{
"sample": 2,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted \u2014 a DATA-vs-oracle contradiction on write-set labels. tests/private_expected.json records T4005 (a document_update that draws its documents.content_hash from deterministic W4 reconstruction) with dispositions.T4005.premises = [\"C1\",\"W3\",\"all required effects exactly once\"], i.e. bare W3. But the agent-visible spec (RPS1_SPEC.md \u00a73/\u00a77 and OUTPUT_CONTRACT.md) mandates " }, { "sample": 3, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "I hunted for an impossibility/contradiction across the graded contract and refuted each candidate with a code-level defense:\n\n1. **schema_sql_sha256 double-source (strongest candidate).** OUTPUT_CONTRACT.md(Deliverable B) saysschema_sql_sha256\"hashes the exact bytes of/app/data/schemas/recovered_schema.sql\", while the verifier asserts it equals sha256_hex(RESTORE_DDL.encode())whereR"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "precision",
"requested": 3,
"observed": 3,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "B3",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "FAIL",
"evidence": "",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "FAIL",
"evidence": ""
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "B4",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "[3 samples, no concrete break] I enumerated every graded decision in tests/vault_gauntlet.py and mapped each to agent-visible spec, then tried to exhibit a hidden requirement.\n\nBreaks attempted and refuted:\n\n1. Hidden word-count / sentence thresholds in the risk panel \u2014 require_risk_footer enforces assert len(words) >= 55 and >= 3 sentence terminators (vault_gauntlet.py). Refuted: both constants are explicitly discl",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "I enumerated every graded decision in tests/vault_gauntlet.py and mapped each to agent-visible spec, then tried to exhibit a hidden requirement.\n\nBreaks attempted and refuted:\n\n1. Hidden word-count / sentence thresholds in the risk panel \u2014 require_risk_footer enforces assert len(words) >= 55 and >= 3 sentence terminators (vault_gauntlet.py). Refuted: both constants are explicitly discl"
},
{
"sample": 2,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Disproof attempts hunted for verifier-baked constants/thresholds/tie-breaks not visible to the agent; each is refuted by an agent-visible spec clause (instruction.md designates /app/data/OUTPUT_CONTRACT.md + RPS1_SPEC.md + schemas + data files as the exhaustive contract, all shipped under environment/data/).\n\nBreaks attempted and their code-level defenses:\n\n1. Verifier-baked selection consta"
},
{
"sample": 3,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "I attempted to surface a graded decision (threshold / convention / precedence) enforced only in tests/ and absent from the agent-visible material. Note the agent-visible spec set is unusually large: environment/data/OUTPUT_CONTRACT.md, RPS1_SPEC.md, README.md, rps1_rules.json, transaction_families.json, object_authority.json, schemas/* are all shipped in the image and instruction.m"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "precision",
"requested": 3,
"observed": 3,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "B5",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "[3 samples, no break] Break attempted: try to show a graded output is not forced by agent-visible material \u2014 i.e., find a divergent-but-consistent recovery that the verifier would still accept, or a graded fact whose value depends on something the agent cannot see. This is not a hidden-mapping/held-out-input regime: the ENTIRE graded input space is disclosed and sealed in environment/data/ (all artifacts/*.jsonl, ", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: try to show a graded output is not forced by agent-visible material \u2014 i.e., find a divergent-but-consistent recovery that the verifier would still accept, or a graded fact whose value depends on something the agent cannot see. This is not a hidden-mapping/held-out-input regime: the ENTIRE graded input space is disclosed and sealed in environment/data/(allartifacts/.jsonl, "
},
{
"sample": 2,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: treat this as an underdetermined hidden-mapping task and construct a spec-consistent rule that yields a different value on a graded output the agent cannot see.\n\nRefutation: The regime precondition "grading is on held-out/unseen inputs" is false. The graded space IS the fully-disclosed sealed package \u2014 every graded output is a deterministic function of the bytes under /app/data,"
},
{
"sample": 3,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: treat this as a hidden-rule/held-out-input regime and find a graded output not fixed by disclosed material. It refutes because none of the three regime conditions hold. (a) The recovery function family is FULLY disclosed, not sampled: environment/data/OUTPUT_CONTRACT.md ("Decision procedure" gates 1\u20137) + environment/data/RPS1_SPEC.md (\u00a71\u2013\u00a79 C1/C2/C3, W1\u2013W4, satisfies_premise m"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "recall",
"requested": 3,
"observed": 3,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "B6",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "[3 samples, no break] I hunted for data anomalies whose handling could change the graded answer and could not surface an accepted wrong answer.\n\nBreak 1 (tie among valid summits): tests/private_expected.json shows candidate_sets[\"1\"] and candidate_sets[\"3\"] are byte-identical ({T1001..T1008}) \u2014 two valid summits with equal included sets, a genuine tie. Attempted to make this yield a non-unique maximum. Refuted: t",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "I hunted for data anomalies whose handling could change the graded answer and could not surface an accepted wrong answer.\n\nBreak 1 (tie among valid summits): tests/private_expected.json shows candidate_sets[\"1\"] and candidate_sets[\"3\"] are byte-identical ({T1001..T1008}) \u2014 two valid summits with equal included sets, a genuine tie. Attempted to make this yield a non-unique maximum. Refuted: t"
},
{
"sample": 2,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted (the one genuine anomaly I could construct): an order-dependent upsert to a shared primary key. Among the 23 included transactions, documents.document_id = 'DOC-002' is written twice: wal-4-1310-49 (T4005 \u2192 version 44, body "\u2026revision 44 for T4005") and wal-4-1450-63 (T4012 \u2192 version 51, body "\u2026revision 51 for T4012"), both INCLUDED_* per tests/private_expected.json ("
},
{
"sample": 3,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "I hunted the sealed graded data (environment/data/artifacts/*.jsonl) for anomalies whose handling could change the graded answer and tried to make each produce an unforced/wrong-but-passing result; every attempt is refuted by an explicitly stated rule plus an exact oracle comparison.\n\nBreaks attempted and defenses:\n\n1. Duplicate admissible effect (T2007). T2007 carries the same effect IDs "
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "recall",
"requested": 3,
"observed": 3,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "C1",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "[3 samples, no break] Break attempted: submit a report-only / boolean-only / empty-database stub (e.g. a marker recovered_pgdata directory plus skeleton JSON files) hoping the aggregate clears. This is refuted by multiple independent, ALL-must-pass probes. tests/test.sh requires pytest exit 0 (status -eq 0 \u2192 reward 1), and every probe in CORE_PROBES plus the 1,024 parametrized risk cases must pass (tests/test_", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: submit a report-only / boolean-only / empty-database stub (e.g. a marker recovered_pgdatadirectory plus skeleton JSON files) hoping the aggregate clears. This is refuted by multiple independent, ALL-must-pass probes.tests/test.sh requires pytest exit 0 (status -eq 0\u2192 reward 1), and every probe inCORE_PROBES plus the 1,024 parametrized risk cases must pass (tests/test_"
},
{
"sample": 2,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: submit degenerate/stub deliverables (e.g., only a report, empty JSON files, a boolean-only validate_recovery.sh, or a marker directory instead of a real cluster) to clear grading without doing the recovery.\n\nRefuted by code-level defenses:\n- Reward is all-or-nothing: tests/test.sh sets reward.txt=1 only when pytest status -eq 0, and every probe in CORE_PROBES plus the 1,"
},
{
"sample": 3,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: submit a degenerate/stub deliverable set (report-only, empty files, or a marker directory instead of a real cluster) and clear the aggregate. Refuted by the verifier's per-probe gauntlet, which is a conjunction of full-fidelity oracle comparisons:\n\n- A report-only or missing-cluster stub fails check_delivery_shell_and_seal \u2014 it requires read_regular_file(VAULT / 'PG_VERSION') =" } ], "sampling": { "vote_class": "recall", "requested": 3, "observed": 3, "stopped_early": false } }, { "check_id": "C2", "severity": "Major", "source": "llm", "status": "PASS", "evidence": "[3 samples, no break] I searched for any tolerance/threshold/aggregate that would admit a materially-wrong answer and every candidate is defeated by exact-equality gating.\n\nBreak attempts and defenses:\n- Off-by-small numeric balance: rejected \u2014 require_cell_stateassertsfetch_cell_rows(sock, port, 'account_balances') == ORACLE['account_balances']exact list equality (tests/vault_gauntlet.py,require_cell_state),", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "I searched for any tolerance/threshold/aggregate that would admit a materially-wrong answer and every candidate is defeated by exact-equality gating.\n\nBreak attempts and defenses:\n- Off-by-small numeric balance: rejected \u2014 require_cell_stateassertsfetch_cell_rows(sock, port, 'account_balances') == ORACLE['account_balances']exact list equality (tests/vault_gauntlet.py,require_cell_state)," }, { "sample": 2, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: submit a materially-wrong recovered state (e.g., one account_balances.balanceoff by 1, or a ledgeramountaltered, or a wrong digest) hoping a numeric tolerance / aggregate score absorbs it. Refuted \u2014 the verifier uses only exact equality, never a tolerance band or aggregate threshold on the graded core:\n\n- Row/state grading is byte-exact:require_cell_stateassertsfetch_"
},
{
"sample": 3,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempts and their code-level defenses:\n\n1. Numeric drift in the recovered ledger/balances (e.g., one account balance off by 1 cent, or a ledger amount altered while keeping sum=0). Refuted: the verifier does exact list-equality against a root-owned oracle, not any tolerance \u2014 require_cell_state asserts fetch_cell_rows(sock, port, rel) == rows and fetch_cell_rows(sock, port, 'account_" } ], "sampling": { "vote_class": "recall", "requested": 3, "observed": 3, "stopped_early": false } }, { "check_id": "C3", "severity": "Major", "source": "llm", "status": "PASS", "evidence": "[3 samples, no break] Break attempted: a solution that hardcodes a shared constant / ignores the sealed input and still clears the verifier. This fails because every graded decision is an exact-equality comparison against values recomputed from the sealed, hash-pinned inputs \u2014 there is no aggregate/threshold/tolerance a wrong-shape answer can slip past.\n\n- No leakage-based hardcode: the oracle lives in /tests/private_",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: a solution that hardcodes a shared constant / ignores the sealed input and still clears the verifier. This fails because every graded decision is an exact-equality comparison against values recomputed from the sealed, hash-pinned inputs \u2014 there is no aggregate/threshold/tolerance a wrong-shape answer can slip past.\n\n- No leakage-based hardcode: the oracle lives in /tests/private_" }, { "sample": 2, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: submit a solution that ignores the sealed /app/dataevidence and simply writes hardcoded literals for every deliverable (export rows, manifest digests, graph, meta values) matching a memorized answer key. Defense 1 \u2014 the answer key is not agent-visible: the verifier loads all expected values fromtests/vault_gauntlet.py ORACLE = json.loads(Path('/tests/private_expected.json')"
},
{
"sample": 3,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempt 1 \u2014 a "hardcoded constant / ignore-input" validator, e.g. validate_recovery.sh that just prints validation_ok logical_state_digest=<constant> and exits 0 without inspecting the vault. Refuted: tests/test_outputs.py:43 registers check_validator_gauntlet_against_opaque_cells (id validator-mutations), which per the contract (environment/data/OUTPUT_CONTRACT.md Deliverable G)"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "recall",
"requested": 3,
"observed": 3,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "C6",
"severity": "Minor",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "I attempted to make a wrong answer pass by injecting extra content into each exact-schema deliverable, and each attempt is refuted by a full-set assertion in tests/vault_gauntlet.py:\n\n- Break: add an extra top-level key or extra relation to recovered_export.json. Defeated \u2014 check_export_wire_image pins the top-level key set with assert set(e) == {'format','database','schema','schema_sql_sha", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "I attempted to make a wrong answer pass by injecting extra content into each exact-schema deliverable, and each attempt is refuted by a full-set assertion in tests/vault_gauntlet.py:\n\n- Break: add an extra top-level key or extra relation to recovered_export.json. Defeated \u2014 check_export_wire_imagepins the top-level key set withassert set(e) == {'format','database','schema','schema_sql_sha"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "C7",
"severity": "Minor",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: substitute JSON booleans for expected integers so True==1/False==0 slips a wrong-typed value past an == compare.\n\n- Manifest deliverable: every integer field (selected_timeline, terminal_lsn, terminal_timeline, record_count, start_lsn, end_lsn, etc.) is first run through enforce_wire_schema(m, 'schemas/recovery_manifest.schema.json') (vault_gauntlet.py enforce", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: substitute JSON booleans for expected integers so True==1/False==0slips a wrong-typed value past an== compare.\n\n- Manifest deliverable: every integer field (selected_timeline, terminal_lsn, terminal_timeline, record_count, start_lsn, end_lsn, etc.) is first run through enforce_wire_schema(m, 'schemas/recovery_manifest.schema.json')(vault_gauntlet.pyenforce"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "C8",
"severity": "Minor",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: submit recovered_export.json that violates the stated canonicalization contract (Deliverable B: "canonical JSON with sorted object keys and compact separators \u2026 exactly one final LF") \u2014 e.g. keys not sorted, spaces after separators, or a missing/extra trailing LF \u2014 hoping the verifier's JSON parse normalizes it away.\n\nDefense: tests/vault_gauntlet.py check_export_wire_image ",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: submit recovered_export.json that violates the stated canonicalization contract (Deliverable B: "canonical JSON with sorted object keys and compact separators \u2026 exactly one final LF") \u2014 e.g. keys not sorted, spaces after separators, or a missing/extra trailing LF \u2014 hoping the verifier's JSON parse normalizes it away.\n\nDefense: tests/vault_gauntlet.py check_export_wire_image "
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "C9",
"severity": "Minor",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: supply an agent output whose top-level or nested object is an instance of an agent-defined class with a permissive __eq__/__hash__ so that == comparisons against ORACLE values always match. This is impossible here because every agent-produced value the verifier compares is obtained by JSON decoding or by PostgreSQL query decoding, both of which yield only builtin Python type",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: supply an agent output whose top-level or nested object is an instance of an agent-defined class with a permissive __eq__/__hash__ so that == comparisons against ORACLE values always match. This is impossible here because every agent-produced value the verifier compares is obtained by JSON decoding or by PostgreSQL query decoding, both of which yield only builtin Python type"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "C10",
"severity": "Minor",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "The only instruction-required configurable override is validate_recovery.sh's optional PGDATA argument (PGDATA=\"${1:-/app/recovered_pgdata}\", solution/solve.py write_validation_script; required by OUTPUT_CONTRACT.md Deliverable G "accepts an optional PGDATA argument whose default is /app/recovered_pgdata"). Break attempted: a validator that ignores $1 and hardcodes /app/recovered_pgdata wo",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "The only instruction-required configurable override is validate_recovery.sh's optional PGDATA argument (PGDATA=\"${1:-/app/recovered_pgdata}\", solution/solve.py write_validation_script; required by OUTPUT_CONTRACT.md Deliverable G "accepts an optional PGDATA argument whose default is /app/recovered_pgdata"). Break attempted: a validator that ignores $1 and hardcodes /app/recovered_pgdata wo"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "C11",
"severity": "Minor",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: find an advertised deliverable/behavior with no exercising test. Every one of the seven advertised deliverables in instruction.md maps to a dedicated verifier probe in tests/test_outputs.py CORE_PROBES (lines ~34\u201347): recovered_pgdata\u2192check_delivery_shell_and_seal (id sealed-filesystem) and check_vault_integrity_and_restart (id postgres-restart); recovery_manifest", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: find an advertised deliverable/behavior with no exercising test. Every one of the seven advertised deliverables in instruction.mdmaps to a dedicated verifier probe intests/test_outputs.py CORE_PROBES(lines ~34\u201347):recovered_pgdata\u2192check_delivery_shell_and_seal(idsealed-filesystem) and check_vault_integrity_and_restart(idpostgres-restart); recovery_manifest"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "C12",
"severity": "Minor",
"source": "llm",
"status": "FAIL",
"evidence": "Correctness of this task cannot be established statically \u2014 the graded outcome depends on live PostgreSQL execution. tests/vault_gauntlet.py running_cell() launches a real PG16 server (pg_ctl ... start, asserting rc==0) and check_delivery_shell_and_seal runs pg_controldata and requires Database cluster state: shut down / Data page checksum version: 1. check_vault_integrity_and_res", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "FAIL", "evidence": "Correctness of this task cannot be established statically \u2014 the graded outcome depends on live PostgreSQL execution. tests/vault_gauntlet.py running_cell() launches a real PG16 server (pg_ctl ... start, asserting rc==0) and check_delivery_shell_and_sealrunspg_controldataand requiresDatabase cluster state: shut down/Data page checksum version: 1. check_vault_integrity_and_res"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "D1",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: submit nothing / leave the pristine container state and rely on the verifier passing on the no-op filesystem. Defense: the verifier's very first core probe check_delivery_shell_and_seal (tests/vault_gauntlet.py) iterates for p in DELIVERABLES: read_regular_file(p), and read_regular_file (tests/vault_gauntlet.py, before = os.lstat(path); assert stat.S_ISREG(...)) calls os.", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: submit nothing / leave the pristine container state and rely on the verifier passing on the no-op filesystem. Defense: the verifier's very first core probe check_delivery_shell_and_seal(tests/vault_gauntlet.py) iteratesfor p in DELIVERABLES: read_regular_file(p), and read_regular_file(tests/vault_gauntlet.py,before = os.lstat(path); assert stat.S_ISREG(...)) calls os."
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "D2",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: find a shipped fixture that raises a parse error under the format the tests/solution assume. The verifier parses JSONL via sealed_rows \u2192 decode_strict_json (tests/vault_gauntlet.py: sealed_rows splits on splitlines(), skips blank lines, and calls decode_strict_json per line, which is json.loads with a parse_constant that only rejects NaN/Infinity). The solution mirro",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: find a shipped fixture that raises a parse error under the format the tests/solution assume. The verifier parses JSONL via sealed_rows \u2192 decode_strict_json (tests/vault_gauntlet.py: sealed_rows splits on splitlines(), skips blank lines, and calls decode_strict_json per line, which is json.loads with a parse_constant that only rejects NaN/Infinity). The solution mirro"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "D3",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempts against environment/Dockerfile:\n\n1. postgresql-16 unavailable on the base image \u2014 Ubuntu 24.04 (Noble) ships PostgreSQL 16 as its default server version; postgresql-16, postgresql-client-16, and postgresql-contrib are all present in the standard 24.04 repos, so apt-get install at Dockerfile:6-7 resolves them without any external PGDG apt source. This also satisfi",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempts against environment/Dockerfile:\n\n1. postgresql-16 unavailable on the base image \u2014 Ubuntu 24.04 (Noble) ships PostgreSQL 16 as its default server version; postgresql-16, postgresql-client-16, and postgresql-contrib are all present in the standard 24.04 repos, so apt-get install at Dockerfile:6-7 resolves them without any external PGDG apt source. This also satisfi"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "D5",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: look for any key/IV/random value generated at build or verifier-setup time that would make grading non-deterministic. (1) environment/Dockerfile only runs apt-get, pip3 install, COPY data /app/data, mkdir, and chmod \u2014 it generates no keys, IVs, or random values; all evidence files are static and pinned by environment/data/artifact_hashes.json and re-checked against ", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: look for any key/IV/random value generated at build or verifier-setup time that would make grading non-deterministic. (1) environment/Dockerfileonly runsapt-get, pip3 install, COPY data /app/data, mkdir, and chmod\u2014 it generates no keys, IVs, or random values; all evidence files are static and pinned byenvironment/data/artifact_hashes.jsonand re-checked against"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "E3",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "[3 samples, no break] Break attempted #1 \u2014 agent drops /app/conftest.py or an /app/vault_gauntlet.py shadow so the verifier imports agent code and forces green. Defeated: tests/test.sh:2-7 runs cd /tests then python3 -I -m pytest ... /tests/test_outputs.py. CWD is /tests, the sole collected arg is /tests/test_outputs.py, and -I (isolated) plus export PYTHONSAFEPATH=1 (test.sh:5) plus export PYTEST_DI", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted #1 \u2014 agent drops /app/conftest.pyor an/app/vault_gauntlet.pyshadow so the verifier imports agent code and forces green. Defeated:tests/test.sh:2-7runscd /teststhenpython3 -I -m pytest ... /tests/test_outputs.py. CWD is /tests, the sole collected arg is /tests/test_outputs.py, and -I(isolated) plusexport PYTHONSAFEPATH=1(test.sh:5) plusexport PYTEST_DI"
},
{
"sample": 2,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: get the verifier to import/collect an agent-authored conftest.py or module from /app (agent-writable) so it can force reward.txt=1. Refuted by the harness plumbing:\n\n- tests/test.sh runs cd /tests then python3 -I -m pytest -p ctrf.main --ctrf /logs/verifier/ctrf.json /tests/test_outputs.py -rA. CWD is /tests (root-owned), not /app, and the sole collection arg is /" }, { "sample": 3, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: force an agent-authored Python module (e.g. /app/conftest.pyor a shadowingvault_gauntlet.py) to be imported by the verifier and short-circuit grading. Refuted by the launch line in tests/test.sh:5-8: it runs cd /teststhenpython3 -I -m pytest ... /tests/test_outputs.pywithPYTEST_DISABLE_PLUGIN_AUTOLOAD=1andPYTHONSAFEPATH=1exported attests/test.sh:4-5. CWD " } ], "sampling": { "vote_class": "recall", "requested": 3, "observed": 3, "stopped_early": false } }, { "check_id": "E4", "severity": "Major", "source": "llm", "status": "PASS", "evidence": "[3 samples, no break] Break attempted: the agent enumerates the filesystem during its run, reads the ground-truth fixture /tests/private_expected.json(which contains the exactauthoritative_state, digests, dispositions, selected timeline, etc.), and simply transcribes those values into /app/recovered_export.json, recovery_manifest.json, and the DB \u2014 bypassing all derivation.\n\nDefense that defeats it: The groun", "sample_outcomes": [ { "sample": 1, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: the agent enumerates the filesystem during its run, reads the ground-truth fixture /tests/private_expected.json(which contains the exactauthoritative_state, digests, dispositions, selected timeline, etc.), and simply transcribes those values into /app/recovered_export.json, recovery_manifest.json, and the DB \u2014 bypassing all derivation.\n\nDefense that defeats it: The groun" }, { "sample": 2, "status": "PASS", "evidence": "Break attempted: an adversarial agent enumerates the filesystem, locates the ground-truth /tests/private_expected.json(theORACLEthe verifier relies on attests/vault_gauntlet.py: ORACLE = json.loads(Path('/tests/private_expected.json').read_text())), reads the exact expected rows/digests, and either (a) fabricates deliverables during the solve phase or (b) plants a root-running validat"
},
{
"sample": 3,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: assume the agent enumerates the filesystem during its 3600s solve phase and reads the ground-truth oracle the verifier depends on \u2014 ORACLE = json.loads(Path('/tests/private_expected.json').read_text()) (tests/vault_gauntlet.py), plus /tests/private_input_hashes.json and /tests/private_schema.sql. Defense: these live under tests/ (the Harbor separate-verifier directory) a"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "recall",
"requested": 3,
"observed": 3,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "E6",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "[3 samples, no break] No archive extraction occurs anywhere in the task. The verifier (tests/vault_gauntlet.py) only reads JSON/JSONL files, runs PostgreSQL utilities (pg_ctl, psql, pg_controldata, pg_checksums), and copies directory trees via shutil.copytree(VAULT, dst, symlinks=False) \u2014 no tarfile, zipfile, or shell tar/unzip calls. The solution (solution/solve.py) likewise reads sealed JSON/JSO",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "NA",
"evidence": "No archive extraction occurs anywhere in the task. The verifier (tests/vault_gauntlet.py) only reads JSON/JSONL files, runs PostgreSQL utilities (pg_ctl, psql, pg_controldata, pg_checksums), and copies directory trees via shutil.copytree(VAULT, dst, symlinks=False) \u2014 no tarfile, zipfile, or shell tar/unzip calls. The solution (solution/solve.py) likewise reads sealed JSON/JSO"
},
{
"sample": 2,
"status": "NA",
"evidence": "No archive extraction occurs anywhere in the submission. The verifier (tests/vault_gauntlet.py) uses shutil.copytree/shutil.rmtree, subprocess (pg_ctl/psql/pg_controldata/pg_checksums), and direct file reads \u2014 no tarfile, zipfile, shutil.unpack_archive, or extractall calls. The solution (solution/solve.py) likewise reads JSON/JSONL, runs initdb/psql, and writes outputs; it never "
},
{
"sample": 3,
"status": "NA",
"evidence": "No archive extraction occurs anywhere in the submission. The verifier tests/vault_gauntlet.py performs only filesystem/DB operations (shutil.copytree, shutil.rmtree, subprocess calls to postgres tools such as pg_ctl, psql, pg_checksums) and JSON/JSONL parsing; there is no tarfile, zipfile, shutil.unpack_archive, or extractall call. solution/solve.py likewise only reads seal"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "recall",
"requested": 3,
"observed": 3,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "E7",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: look for a retained/copyable reference oracle or solver the agent could preserve/invoke to shortcut the work. The only complete answer key is /tests/private_expected.json, read into ORACLE at tests/vault_gauntlet.py (ORACLE = json.loads(Path('/tests/private_expected.json').read_text())) \u2014 a verifier-image fixture, not present in the agent environment (separate-verifier for",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: look for a retained/copyable reference oracle or solver the agent could preserve/invoke to shortcut the work. The only complete answer key is /tests/private_expected.json, read into ORACLE at tests/vault_gauntlet.py (ORACLE = json.loads(Path('/tests/private_expected.json').read_text())) \u2014 a verifier-image fixture, not present in the agent environment (separate-verifier for"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
},
{
"check_id": "C13",
"severity": "Major",
"source": "llm",
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: find an instruction promise of partial/graduated credit that the binary reward path contradicts. instruction.md states all-or-nothing grading \u2014 "Each deliverable must satisfy every structural, semantic, ... requirement" and "That contract preserves every exact value, member, sort order, edge rule, phrase, check, and acceptance/rejection case; none are optional" (instruction.md, fi",
"sample_outcomes": [
{
"sample": 1,
"status": "PASS",
"evidence": "Break attempted: find an instruction promise of partial/graduated credit that the binary reward path contradicts. instruction.md states all-or-nothing grading \u2014 "Each deliverable must satisfy every structural, semantic, ... requirement" and "That contract preserves every exact value, member, sort order, edge rule, phrase, check, and acceptance/rejection case; none are optional" (instruction.md, fi"
}
],
"sampling": {
"vote_class": "standard",
"requested": 1,
"observed": 1,
"stopped_early": false
}
}
]