distinguish between polyphony and monophony in pia...

On piano, monophony and polyphony are about texture—how many independent musical lines you’re playing, not how many fingers you’re using.

Monophony (single line)

Definition:
Monophony = one melodic line, with no independent accompaniment.

On piano, that means:

• You’re playing only one note at a time, or
• Several notes in unison/octaves that all move together like one melody.

Piano examples:

• Right hand plays a simple melody alone, no left hand.
• Both hands play the same melody in octaves (e.g., both hands playing the same tune together, just higher and lower).
• A scale played one note at a time.

Even if you use ten fingers, if everything is moving as a single line, it’s still monophonic.

---

Polyphony (many independent lines)

Definition:
Polyphony = two or more independent melodic lines happening at the same time.

On piano, that usually means:

• The right hand has its own melody, and
• The left hand also has a different melody, not just chord “background”.
• Or one hand is weaving two lines (like a melody plus an inner counter-melody).

These lines:

• Have their own shapes and rhythms.
• Can imitate each other (like in a canon or fugue).
• Don’t just move together like block chords.

Piano examples:

• A Bach Invention or Fugue, where you can clearly “follow” two or more voices.
• Left hand plays a moving bass line, right hand plays another distinct melody that isn’t just following the bass rhythm.
• A hymn-style piece where inner voices also move with their own direction, not just filling out chords.

---

Common confusion: chords vs polyphony

• If your right hand plays a melody and the left hand plays simple chords that support it, that texture is usually called homophonic, not strictly polyphonic:
  • Melody = main line
  • Chords = accompaniment, not real independent “voices”

Polyphony specifically cares about multiple real melodies at once, not just “more than one note”.

---

How to hear the difference on piano

Ask yourself while listening or playing:

1. Can I sing two different lines separately?

   • Yes → likely polyphony
   • No, it’s just one tune with backing → likely monophony or homophony

2. Do the hands have their own rhythms and shapes?

   • If the left hand does more than just hold chords, and feels like its own tune, that’s polyphonic.

---

If you tell me a piece you’re working on, I can point out which bars are monophonic and which are polyphonic and give you practice tips for bringing out each voice.